The Beatles Live - Star Club (Version 2)

 Cover 
Label: 
Catalogue No.: 
PC157 / 158 Version 2
Format : 
CDR & Jewel case
Origin: 
US/Internet
Availability : Jan 2008
Duration:D1
50:49
50:51 (inc T.O.C)
D2
63:46
63:48 (inc T.O.C)
Matrix: NONE
CD ID: D1 : 310be915
D2 : 420ef216
Reviews:
 
Belmo's Beatleg News logo  
 ??
910 Logo
V?N?
Beatlemania logo   
??
  Core Disc or Choice     

Cover

 
Inside Cover 
Back

Inside Cover

 

Rear Tray

 

Comments:

These will never be Studio quality , but here they are presented in a way that not only is very listenable but also enjoyable. nevr thought Iwould ever say that.The liner notes really say it all , this is by far the best release of this material to date and if you get the opportunity, don't think not yet another Star Club release, pick it but rememberAs always, Purple Chick discs are fan created and NEVER FOR SALE.

It should be noted that he rear tray art does not show the NON Beatles tracks and the inner cover artwork was slowly tweaked to completion with three versions circulating .

Reason for Upgrade

Here's what happened.....

The full third version of "A Taste Of Honey",magically appeared, just after Star Club was released. It turns out that some dialogue that we placed on disc one belongs just before it. So we cut it out of disc one, put it at the end of "Hippy Hippy Shake" and did a minor tweak to "Money" just for the sake of continuity. A change of the info file and inside artwork to reflect this, and we're all done.

So to recap the following tracks were updated :

Disc 1 - Track 19, Falling Love with You

Disc 2 Tracks 15 -17 , Hippy Hippy Shake , A Taste Of Honey , Money

Liner Notes:

This release clears up a lot of speculation about the Beatles’ Star Club tapes, thanks to an unedited and unprocessed source tape (for which we cannot thank Darthdisc and the Darthelves enough). Although the recording dates are still guesses, we now know the correct order for about 2/3 of the songs. Even so, the second half of disc one is sequenced based more on smooth transitions than solid set list information.

We tried to make sure every Star Club sound was accounted for, but not repeated: auditioning many “Live At The Star Club” CDs and LPS on a number of labels. Even so, we used Darthdisc’s unprocessed tape wherever possible. As well as offering upgrades and previously unheard chat “Red Hot,” though still incomplete, is twice as long as before. “Red Sails…” now has an extra verse compared with the released version, while “I Saw Her Standing There” on disc two has an extra guitar solo. Conversely, we removed looped portions of “I’m Gonna Sit Right Down…”, “Twist And Shout” and “I Remember You.”

It’s by no means perfect, but it’s the best we have at the moment. And it’s the first time we’ve listened to the Star Club tapes in years. Hopefully you’ll gain a new appreciation for these historic recordings as well.

All tracks mono, at the correct speed, and eq’d for the most coherent listening experience. Enjoy!

As always, Purple Chick discs are fan created and NEVER FOR SALE.

Track Listing:

Disc 1

25(?) December, 1962, Star Club, Hamburg, Germany
V1+2Song VersionComments
Source
1 3:02 Be-Bop A-Lula vocal: Fred Fascher
+
2 3:35 I Saw Her Standing There
3 2:36 Hallelujah I Love Her So vocal: Horst Fascher
+
4 1:03 Red Hot incomplete
5 2:40 Sheila
6 2:29 Kansas City/Hey Hey Hey Hey
7 3:15Shimmy Like Kate
8 2:35 Reminiscing
9 2:33 Red Sails In The Sunset
10 3:55 Sweet Little Sixteen
11 2:57 Roll Over Beethoven
12 1:58 A Taste Of Honey incomplete

 

25(?) December, 1962, Star Club, Hamburg, Germany
V2V1Song VersionComments
Source
13 2:36 2:36 Ask Me Why
+
14 1:49 1:49 Long Tall Sally
15 2:35 2:35 Besame Mucho
16 1:43 1:43 I’m Gonna Sit Right Down And Cry (Over You) incomplete
172:282:28Twist And Shoutincomplete
+ +
182:202:20Mr. Moonlight
+
192:082:40Falling In Love Again
+
+
201:571:57I’m Talking About You
+ +
211:331:33I Remember You
+

 

 Uncut Disc Art Uncut Disc Art

Uncut Disc Art

Disc 2

28(?) December, 1962, Star Club, Hamburg, Germany
V1+2Song VersionComments
Source
1 2:28 Nothin’ Shakin’ (But The Leaves On The Trees)
+
2 3:35 I Saw Her Standing There
3 3:41 To Know Her Is To Love Her
4 3:20 Everybody’s Trying To Be My Baby
5 2:43 Till There Was You
6 3:26 Where Have You Been All My Life?
+ +
7 2:24 Lend Me Your Combvocal: Bobby Thompson (poss.) (or Tony Sheridan?)
8 2:29 Your Feet’s Too Big
9 2:58 I’m Talking About You
10 3:04 A Taste Of Honey
11 3:22 Matchbox
+ +
12 4:56 Little Queeni
+
132:56Roll Over Beethoven

 

31(?) December, 1962, Star Club, Hamburg, Germany
V2V1Song VersionComments
Source
14 2:022:02 Road Runner
+
+
15 2:261:48 Hippy Hippy Shake
+ +
16 2:090:52 A Taste Of Honey
+
173:393:39Moneyvocal: Bobby Thompson

 

Bonus Tracks
31(?) December, 1962, Star Club, Hamburg, Germany
V1+2Song VersionComments
Source
182:10 Sparkling Brown Eyesvocal: Keith Hardie
192:46 Lovesick Bluesvocal: John Frankland
202:09 First Taste Of Lovevocal: Bobby Thompson
212:59 Dizzy Miss Lizzy vocal: Kingsize Taylor
222:01Hully Gully*vocal: Cliff Bennett

 

Sources

N/A

Unbooted Upgrade
Live! At the Star Club in Hamburg, Germany 1962 (?)- Teichiku
Road Runner - Unknown
Live At The Star Club, In Hamburg:1962. - Lingasong
At The Star-Club. 1962 Vol. II (?)- Sony
Live At The Star Club, In Hamburg:1962. - Batz

N/A

Third Reich Tape Source
fuegoentertainment.net

 

 Uncut Disc Art Uncut Disc Art

Alternate Fan Created Disc Art

 

Artwork

 
Gatefold Cover
Inner Art
Booklet
Inner Tray Art
Comment
Y
Y
N
Y

 

Inner Artwork

Version 1

Disc 2

Track 15 - Source: Teichiku

Track 16 - 'Fragment'

Source: fuegoentertainment.net + Road Runer

two track 17's

 

Inner Original

Version 2a

Disc 2

Track 15 - Source: Road Runner + Batz + fuegoentertainment.net

Track 16 - Fragment removed

Source: fuegoentertainment.net + Road Runer

two track 17's

Inner  Version 2  errors x2

Version 2b

Disc 2

Track 16 - Fragment removed

Source: fuegoentertainment.net + Road Runer

Track Numbering corrected

Inner  Version 2  errors x1

 


ALL Pages, Data and Images are for REFERENCE PURPOSE ONLY.

The collated information is from hundreds of sources, I am unable to verify the accuracy of any information implied or provided .

I neither own these discs or know how to obtain them , so any Corrections or New material is always appreciated.

This pages is a working document, last updated on the 08-Feb-2008

HOME

LABELS


Copyright © Chris Johnson 2008.